Old Moe Guide Service

Based in Dutch John, Utah, Old Moe Guide Service positions itself as a premier outfitter for anglers looking to tackle the legendary Green River. Owned and operated by Doug and Shelly Roberts, this service has garnered a strong reputation, reflected in a high average rating from dozens of clients. Their core business revolves around providing guided fishing trips on a world-renowned tailwater fishery known for its crystal-clear water and dense trout population. However, a deep dive into customer experiences reveals a spectrum of outcomes, ranging from trips of a lifetime to days marked by disappointment. This detailed analysis offers a balanced view for those considering their services for future fishing vacations.

The Hallmarks of Success: Expert Guides and Abundant Catches

The vast majority of feedback for Old Moe Guide Service is overwhelmingly positive, with clients frequently describing their experiences in superlative terms. A common thread is the exceptional quality of the guides. Individuals like Noah, Cori, Dan, Cody, Spencer, and Tyler are repeatedly praised for their professionalism, knowledge, and engaging personalities. One client recounted a float trip with Noah as "one of the best experiences of my life," highlighting how the guide helped him land his first-ever brown trout on a dry fly. Similarly, a "girls weekend" trip was made memorable by guides Cori and Dan, who were described as "absolutely fabulous." Cori, in particular, was lauded for being extremely knowledgeable, fun, and successful at getting her clients into "a ton of fish."

These reports underscore the value of a skilled guide in transforming a simple fishing day into a significant event. The guides at Old Moe are often portrayed as more than just navigators; they are patient teachers and hardworking partners on the water. Co-owner Doug Roberts is singled out as an "exceptional guide," praised for his relentless effort in changing flies and leaders and for his technique of rowing back upstream to allow anglers to fish a productive run multiple times. This level of dedication is what many anglers seek when investing in expert fishing guides.

The results of this expert guidance are often spectacular. Reports of catching so many rainbow trout that they lost count, or a single boat landing over 60 brown and rainbow trout in two days, are common among the five-star reviews. These stories of high catch rates solidify the Green River's reputation and demonstrate what is possible when conditions, skills, and guidance align perfectly. For those planning group outings, such as a "boys trip" or a family adventure, the service appears well-equipped to manage multiple boats and ensure a positive collective experience.

A Note of Caution: Managing Expectations

While the positive testimonials paint a compelling picture, it is crucial for potential customers to consider the less favorable feedback to form a complete and realistic view. Not every trip results in a bounty of fish. One detailed account from a client highlights a significantly different experience that serves as an important counterpoint. This particular angler, on an all-day trip costing over $800, caught zero fish while her partner caught four. The experience was marred by a guide who was described as quiet and whose instructions felt contradictory—at one point suggesting a quick pull and at another suggesting letting the line run.

Furthermore, the client felt her line was out of the water more than in it due to constant adjustments for water depth and speed. The experience was capped off by the guide's comment that they "usually catch 25 per trip," a remark that, while possibly unintentional, only amplified the client's disappointment. This review provides a critical lesson for anyone booking fishing trip packages: success is never guaranteed. Factors like weather, water conditions, the specific guide's communication style, and angler skill all play a role.

This incident underscores the importance of the client-guide relationship. A successful day on the water often depends on clear communication and aligned expectations. Prospective clients should be proactive in discussing their skill level, goals for the day, and what they hope to learn. While Old Moe Guide Service clearly has a roster of highly effective guides, this experience shows that the match between a guide and a client can significantly impact the outcome. It is a reminder that when choosing a fishing guide, personal recommendations can be invaluable.

Services and Operations

Old Moe Guide Service is a dedicated fly fishing outfitter specializing in drift boat float trips along the A, B, and C sections of the Green River. Their location in Dutch John provides immediate access to this celebrated fishery. The business is also listed as a "school," which aligns with client reports of guides being excellent instructors, capable of teaching everything from basic casting to advanced techniques. This educational component is a significant part of their value proposition, making them a suitable choice for both novice anglers and experienced fishers looking to refine their skills on a challenging river.

The company's website, run by owners Doug and Shelly Roberts, provides information on their team of guides, many of whom have extensive experience and specialized training, including degrees in fisheries and recreation management. This background suggests a deep, professional commitment to both the sport and the local ecosystem. While their Google Business Profile lists them as open 24 hours, this likely refers to their availability for bookings and inquiries rather than constant physical operation. It is always best to confirm details and availability directly via their official channels.

Final Considerations

Ultimately, Old Moe Guide Service stands as a highly competent and largely celebrated professional guide service in a prime location for Green River trout fishing. The wealth of positive reviews celebrating their knowledgeable, hardworking, and personable guides speaks volumes about their ability to deliver exceptional Utah fishing adventures. The stories of abundant catches and memorable days affirm their status as a top-tier choice.

However, potential clients should approach any guided trip with managed expectations. The negative review, though an outlier, is a valuable piece of data, highlighting that a high price tag doesn't automatically guarantee a high catch count. It emphasizes the need for open communication and the understanding that fly fishing is an activity subject to many variables. By being clear about goals and skill levels, clients can better position themselves for a successful and enjoyable day on the water with this well-regarded outfitter, making their investment in outdoor adventure travel a rewarding one.