909 & Vine

Located in Shelbyville, Illinois, 909 & Vine presents itself as a luxurious short-stay vacation rental, blending the historic charm of a renovated 19th-century house with a robust list of modern amenities. This property aims to provide a high-end experience for guests, whether they are in town for a family getaway, a fishing competition, or a wedding. However, customer experiences paint a complex picture, highlighting both exceptional features and at least one alarming, significant concern that potential visitors must seriously consider before booking a trip.

The property is managed by R4 Hospitality and is frequently described in glowing terms across various platforms. It boasts accommodations for up to 10 guests, featuring a flexible interior design that allows living spaces to be converted into additional bedrooms or even a formal dining room for events. This adaptability makes it a compelling option for group travel and special occasions. The list of amenities is extensive and is clearly a primary selling point. Guests have access to a heated in-ground swimming pool, a hot tub usable even in colder weather, both gas and wood-burning fire pits, and meticulously maintained gardens. Inside, the house is equipped with smart home technology, multiple smart TVs with streaming capabilities, an Xbox One console, laundry facilities on both floors, and a fully stocked kitchen. The master suite is particularly well-appointed, with its own full bathroom, mini-fridge, and Keurig coffee maker.

The Appeal: A Premier Destination for Events and Leisure

A consistent theme among positive reviews is the sheer beauty and thoughtful outfitting of the home. Many guests celebrate the meticulous decorations, describing the atmosphere as warm, inviting, and glamorous while still feeling comfortable and cozy. The combination of historic architecture—like its fireplaces and wooden staircase—with modern comforts creates a unique and appealing environment. This aesthetic quality is so pronounced that photographers are reportedly “over the moon” to shoot there, making it a prime location for wedding-related photo opportunities.

One of the strongest advantages of 909 & Vine is its location, particularly for those attending events at Spruce St. Studios, a popular wedding venue situated just across the street. This proximity offers unparalleled convenience for wedding parties, eliminating travel logistics and providing a spacious, elegant home base for preparations and post-celebration relaxation. This positions 909 & Vine as a top-tier choice for wedding accommodation. Furthermore, its fenced-in backyard and welcoming policy for up to two dogs (under 50 lbs, for a fee) make it an excellent option for those seeking pet-friendly travel. Families with children are also drawn to the secure outdoor space and, of course, the pool. One reviewer noted these features were the initial draw for their quiet getaway from Chicago.

A Critical Health and Safety Concern

Despite the numerous positive testimonials, a recent and extremely serious issue has been raised that cannot be overlooked. A review from just a few months ago reported a bat infestation in the house's attic. The guest described a large quantity of bats exiting through a visible hole in the soffit and, more disturbingly, a pervasive smell of bat urine and feces on the second floor of the home. The reviewer gave the property a one-star rating and stated that the owner had been notified of this hazardous situation.

This is not a minor inconvenience; it is a significant health risk. Bat guano can harbor the fungus Histoplasma capsulatum, which, when its spores are inhaled, can cause a lung infection called histoplasmosis. This infection can lead to severe respiratory problems, especially in individuals with compromised immune systems. Furthermore, while rare, bats are known carriers of the rabies virus. An active infestation, characterized by strong odors and visible entry points, suggests a well-established colony that requires professional remediation. The accumulation of guano can also cause structural damage over time. For any establishment offering tourist accommodation, such a condition is unacceptable and poses a direct threat to guest safety.

Weighing the Pros and Cons

For prospective renters, the decision to book 909 & Vine requires careful deliberation. On one hand, the property offers a wealth of premium features that promise a luxurious and memorable stay. The combination of a private pool, hot tub, beautiful decor, and strategic location is hard to match in the area. It is clearly well-suited for family vacations, group gatherings, and as a support hub for local events. The host is often described as generous, communicative, and accommodating, with many guests vowing to return.

On the other hand, the unresolved question of the bat infestation is a critical flaw. The review detailing this issue is recent and specific. While other reviews since that time have been positive, none directly address or refute the claim. It is possible the issue was dealt with swiftly and effectively, but without confirmation, a significant risk remains. It's worth noting that some other guests have mentioned that the beds were uncomfortably soft, but this is a minor, subjective complaint compared to the potential health hazard.

Final Considerations for Potential Guests

Before committing to a stay at 909 & Vine, it is imperative to perform due diligence. The property is marketed as a high-end form of lodging services, and with that comes an expectation of a safe and sanitary environment. The most direct course of action would be to contact the owner or property manager, Renee Tucker, and ask for a direct, transparent update on the bat situation. Inquiries should be specific: Has the property been inspected by a professional wildlife removal service? Has the colony been removed? Has the attic been professionally cleaned and sanitized to eliminate hazardous materials like guano? And has the entry point been sealed to prevent re-entry?

Ultimately, 909 & Vine holds the potential to be a superb holiday home. Its amenities and aesthetic charm are well-documented. However, the shadow of a serious health and safety concern requires caution. Renters must prioritize their well-being by verifying that this critical issue has been fully and professionally resolved before making a reservation.