Conman’s

Operating since 1995 from its base on the shores of Lake Phelps in Creswell, North Carolina, Conman's Guide Service & Lodging has established a formidable reputation not as a conventional travel agency, but as a highly specialized tour operator for outdoor enthusiasts. Owned and operated by Mike and Connie Noles, the business focuses on curating immersive hunting excursions and nature-based getaways. The overwhelming consensus from client feedback paints a picture of a business that excels in delivering memorable, successful, and deeply personal experiences. However, its highly specific focus means it is an ideal choice for a certain type of traveler, while likely being unsuitable for others.

The Strengths: Expertise and Genuine Hospitality

The primary draw for clients engaging with Conman's is the high level of expertise in its guided services. Reviews consistently celebrate the success of their trips, with hunters frequently mentioning they "filled our tags." This outcome is attributed to the hard work and knowledge of the guides, with individuals like Carson, Taylor, and Zane receiving specific praise for their dedication. One client noted that the crew "worked very hard to put us on birds," while another described a swan hunt as the "best experience I've had hunting in a very long time." This level of success is crucial for any business offering adventure travel, and Conman's appears to deliver consistently across its specialized offerings, which include hunts for Tundra Swan, Black Bear, Whitetail Deer, turkey, and other waterfowl.

Beyond the technical skill of the guides, the service is defined by a layer of personal hospitality that sets it apart. Multiple reviews highlight Mike and Connie Noles as "amazing hosts and excellent cooks," creating a welcoming atmosphere that transforms a commercial transaction into a cherished memory. This family-run feel is a significant asset; clients feel welcomed and cared for from start to finish. The business itself states a mission to operate in a "Christian and family oriented environment," a philosophy that clearly resonates with its clientele. This approach makes their all-inclusive trips, which often include food and lodging, feel less like a package and more like a stay with knowledgeable friends.

Diverse Offerings and Quality Accommodations

While hunting is the main event, Conman's leverages its prime location on the 16,500-acre Lake Phelps to offer a broader range of outdoor recreation. The availability of kayak rentals provides an alternative activity for families or non-hunting members of a group. One particularly telling review recounts how the staff advised against renting kayaks when the lake was too rough, prioritizing customer safety over a sale. This demonstrates a level of integrity and customer care that builds significant trust.

Accommodations are another key component of their service. Described by a guest as a "nice and cozy" house with "great prices," the lodging is an integral part of the experience. The business offers fully furnished cottages, positioning itself not just as a guide service but also as a provider of comfortable vacation rentals. This combination allows them to offer comprehensive vacation packages that cater to hunters, families, and anyone seeking a retreat in a natural setting. Hunting packages for black bear, for instance, are listed as including food, lodging, trophy and meat prep, and transportation, providing a seamless experience for the client.

Considerations and Potential Drawbacks

Despite the stellar reviews, potential customers should be aware of several factors. The most significant is the highly specialized nature of the business. Conman's is not a general-purpose travel agency; its identity is deeply rooted in hunting culture. For those seeking authentic, expertly managed guided hunting trips, it is an exceptional choice. However, travelers without an interest in hunting or field sports would find the primary services mismatched to their needs.

Furthermore, the location in Washington County is rural. This is a major advantage for its target audience, offering an escape and access to over 10,000 acres of private hunting land. For visitors accustomed to urban amenities, extensive dining options, or varied entertainment, the remote setting could feel isolating. The appeal of Conman's is the immersion in nature, and clients should have expectations aligned with that reality.

Finally, while the value is consistently praised, specialized services like these require a significant investment. A black bear hunt, for example, is a premium package with a corresponding price tag. Given the personalized attention, high success rate, and inclusive nature of the packages, the cost is justified for serious enthusiasts. However, it's a considerable expense that requires planning. Due to its strong reputation and the limited number of spaces available for certain hunts, booking well in advance is likely essential, particularly during peak seasons.

Final Assessment

Conman's Guide Service & Lodging stands out as a leader in its niche. It has successfully combined expert field knowledge with genuine, family-style hospitality to build a loyal and appreciative client base. The strengths lie in the proven success of its hunting excursions, the personal touch from the owners and staff, and the quality of its accommodations and all-inclusive packages. The potential drawbacks are less about failures in service and more about the business's focused identity. It is an exemplary tour operator for a specific market—the outdoor enthusiast and hunter. For individuals within that market, Conman's offers a comprehensive, reliable, and highly-rated experience that consistently exceeds expectations.